Civics 101: Immigration Myths vs. Facts

Civics 101: Immigration Myths vs. Facts

Independence Day Edition: Oh, The Irony

TL;DR: America wouldn’t exist without immigrants, but they’re being demonized by people whose own families came here the same way. Let’s set the record straight.


Because of the growing push to sanitize America and make everyone here look, speak, and believe one way, entire communities are being criminalized and blamed for systemic issues that are not their fault.

While we light fireworks in honor of freedom and the fight for independence, the facts about immigration are twisted beyond recognition.

Take this clip where Sam Seder calls out Patrick Bet-David and crew for falsely claiming over 2 million Social Security numbers were handed out to undocumented immigrants.

Spoiler: they weren’t.

Those SSNs were issued under Enumeration Before Entry (EBE), a legal, Trump-era program that assigns Social Security numbers to lawfully-admitted immigrants before arrival, so they can start working, paying taxes, and complying with U.S. systems from day one.

Seder: “The amount of misinformation, from every single person, all of you, was astonishing to me.”

To add to the level of misinformation here, PBD’s own family benefited from the same kind of program. But sure, go off.

TRUTH: There is no America without immigrants.

Immigrants are essential to the U.S. economy, making up a large share of the workforce in agriculture, construction, caregiving, and service industries. Many pay taxes, including undocumented workers, contributing billions annually through payroll and sales taxes. And contrary to the noise, immigrants commit fewer crimes than native-born citizens.

Let’s be clear about who’s being targeted.
The majority of immigrants having their doors kicked in or being forced into unmarked vans by armed, masked cowards aren’t “illegals” hiding in shadows. They’re people who came here legally, followed the rules, and work the hardest jobs in the country, growing, picking, building, and cleaning. They’re not stealing anything.

Unless your ancestors were Indigenous to this land or were brought here in chains, you are here because someone in your family immigrated.

If we are to celebrate one truth, we must hold the others with equal weight.

We created this simple table to clarify the difference between legal immigration statuses.

Immigration Status Comparison

U.S. Citizen

Already a U.S. citizen by birth or naturalization. Protected from deportation.

Green Card Holder

A lawful permanent resident. Can apply for citizenship after 5 years, or 3 if married to a U.S. citizen. Deportable only for serious crimes or fraud.

Visa Holder

“Visa holder” covers many categories – some allow work (like H-1B), others don’t (like tourist visas). Most are temporary, and overstaying or violating terms can lead to deportation.

Refugee (legal and protected under U.S. and international law)

Applies from outside the U.S. and is legally admitted, usually through a UN or international resettlement program. Must apply for a green card after 1 year, and may apply for citizenship after 5 years total in the U.S.  Deportation is rare but possible.

Asylee

Applies from within the U.S. or at the border. Must apply for a green card after 1 year of asylum; can apply for citizenship 5 years after that. Protected status, but not immune from deportation.

TPS Holder

Temporary Protected Status is granted during crisis in one’s home country. Must reapply regularly and have a valid work permit (EAD). Can’t apply for citizenship through TPS alone.

DACA Recipient

DACA offers temporary protection and work authorization with an EAD. It is not a legal immigration status and can be changed or ended through executive action. Not a pathway to citizenship.

Undocumented

Entered the country without inspection or overstayed a visa. No legal status, work authorization, or path to citizenship. High risk of deportation.

Have a myth you’d like us to fact-check next? Let us know.


✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?

🗣️ Add Your Voice – Submit your responses to our Good, Bad, Change poll.

💌 Donate Stamps – SOS: Stamp out Silence

Give – Help us build a world where no one is forgotten

Kurtis & Joe Part 2: The Rule of Prayer

Kurtis & Joe Part 2: The Rule of Prayer

This is part two in our series featuring Kurtis & Joe. If you missed the first one, you can catch up here.

Before they ever spoke, Kurtis could tell that Joe didn’t belong. He was quiet, lost, and clearly unprepared for prison. What happened next defied every stereotype of incarceration, and changed both of their lives.

In this second message, Kurtis writes about what it meant to look out for someone else, and the spiritual rule that carried them through Joe’s first six years inside.

Coming Soon:

In our next post, Kurtis goes deeper into Joe’s story, learns about his wife Edna, and respecting small wonders.


Our Linktree is live! One easy place to find everything we’re sharing, watching, posting, and building.

✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?

🗣️ Add Your Voice – Submit your responses to our Good, Bad, Change poll 

💌 Donate Stamps – SOS: Stamp out Silence!

Give – Help us build a world where no one is forgotten

Scroll down and comment below if you’ve ever had a friend like this

Kurtis & Joe Part 2: The Rule of Prayer

Letters From Prison: Kurtis & Joe, Part 1 – Coffee and Trust

This week, we’re sharing something extra special with our Letters From Prison series.

Every week we get touching letters from inside. Some land quietly, like a sparrow on a windowsill (you’ll read about that in Part 3), and end up turning into one of our most meaningful connections.

This is one of those stories.

In October 2022, I received a message from Kurtis in an Illinois prison. He wasn’t writing for himself, but for his celly, Joe.

Kurtis, knowing his transfer to a different institution was imminent, hoped someone on the outside could step in as a friend until it was Joe’s turn to move.

Their story begins with this first message from Kurtis.

Coming Tomorrow in Part 2:

In a place where most look out only for themselves, Kurtis quietly takes on the care of his new celly Joe.


Our Linktree is live! One easy place to find everything we’re sharing, watching, posting, and building.

✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?

🗣️ Add Your Voice – Submit your responses to our Good, Bad, Change poll 

🤲 Get Involved – Help behind the scenes

💌 Donate Stamps – SOS: Stamp out Silence!

Give – Help us build a world where no one is forgotten

Scroll down and comment below if you’ve ever had a friend like this

Letters From Prison: Felicia in Florida

Letters From Prison: Felicia in Florida

This letter came to us in back in 2017. Felicia had already served more than 20 years, and hoped to find connection before her release. We’re thrilled to share that she’s now free, though we haven’t been able to locate her. If anyone knows where Felicia is today, we’d love to reconnect and maybe share this post with her. Felicia, if you’re reading this: we see you. And we’re rooting for you.

📚 Fact‑Check Friday: Do Prisons Make Us Safer?

📚 Fact‑Check Friday: Do Prisons Make Us Safer?

🎯 Myth

Prisons Make Us Safer

Victoria Law’s book Prisons Make Us Safer: And 20 Other Myths about Mass Incarceration challenges this and other commonly held assumptions It’s a concise, accessible read perfect for educators and activists. Read Nicole Frisch-Scott’s excellent review here.

Non-fiction. By Victoria Law. 2021. 240 pages
An accessible guide for activists, educators, and all who are interested in understanding how the prison system oppresses communities and harms individuals.

Time Periods: 20th Century, 1961, 21st Century, All US History

Themes: Criminal Justice & Incarceration, Immigration, Laws & Citizen Rights

Order online

 


Over the past 40 years, the number of people behind bars in the United States has increased by 500%.

Journalist Victoria Law explains how racism and social control were the catalysts for mass incarceration and have continued to be its driving force: from the post-Civil War laws that states passed to imprison former slaves, to the laws passed under the “War Against Drugs” campaign that disproportionately imprison Black people.

Law challenges the common belief that incarceration enhances public safety, arguing instead that the prison system often harms individuals and communities.

✅ The Reality:

High incarceration ≠ low crime: Multiple studies show that even countries with extremely high incarceration rates don’t see proportionately lower violent crime. 

Incarceration doesn’t deter everyone: Crimes persist despite harsh punishments. Meanwhile, research finds more deterrent and rehabilitative potential in community-based approaches.

It perpetuates harm: Prison also exacts massive financial, social, and intergenerational costs for individuals and communities. Many end up in jail again within three years.

Alternatives work – and cost less
From education to mental health treatment to community supervision improvements, proven alternatives save money and reduce recidivism.

A short prison sentence may stop one crime, but a community investment stops many more.

Why It Matters

When we believe prisons = safety, we invest in more cages, less community, and more patterns of harm. But if we shift the narrative and insist on prevention, healing, and repair, we find smarter, more humane paths forward.

Juneteenth: What Is Freedom?

Juneteenth: What Is Freedom?

Juneteenth marks the day in 1865 when the last enslaved Black Americans were officially freed, more than two years after the Emancipation Proclamation. It’s a day of jubilation and grief, a celebration of delayed liberation that still echoes today in the lives of those who remain caged.

More than 160 years later, millions of people, disproportionately Black and Brown, are still waiting to be free.

And not just free from bars and razor wire, but from surveillance, exclusion, and the systems that seek to erase them.


A Brief Timeline of Freedom Deferred

1863 – Emancipation Proclamation
Lincoln declares all enslaved people in Confederate states “forever free.” But enforcement relies on Union troops, and liberation is staggered and partial.

1865 – Juneteenth
June 19. Union soldiers arrive in Galveston, Texas, two and a half years later, to enforce the Proclamation. Freedom finally reaches the last enslaved Americans.

1877 – End of Reconstruction
Federal troops are withdrawn. Southern states rapidly enact Jim Crow laws, gutting Black political and economic gains.

1896 – Plessy v. Ferguson
The Supreme Court upholds segregation under the doctrine of “separate but equal,” legalizing apartheid for nearly 60 more years.

1964 – Civil Rights Act
Outlaws segregation and discrimination, a major victory of the Civil Rights Movement, though resistance remains fierce.

1994 – Federal Crime Bill
Mass incarceration explodes. Mandatory minimums, three-strikes laws, and prison construction surge, disproportionately targeting Black communities.

Today
Over 1 million Black Americans are under carceral control – in prison, on probation, on parole.
Slavery’s exception clause remains in the 13th Amendment.
The promise of freedom? Still unfinished.


Who Still Waits to Be Free?

This week we revived our blog series: Letters From Prison.
The first entry was from Bradley, writing us from a federal prison in Colorado. In his letter, he talks about one of the many humiliations people endure behind bars.

Bradley’s voice, and the voices of so many others, are the reason we do this work.

Every week, we’ll share more letters from people in prison. More truth-telling. More messages of delayed freedom.


✊🏾 On Juneteenth and Every Day

“Nobody’s free until everybody’s free.” — Fannie Lou Hamer

This Juneteenth, we honor not just this history, but the people still trapped by its legacy.

We listen to the ones still waiting.
We lift their voices.
And we keep pushing.


Image by khema sok from Pixabay.

Letters From Prison: Bradley in Colorado

Letters From Prison: Bradley in Colorado

Every day, we receive letters from people in prison.

Our Letters From Prison series is a raw and unfiltered look into life behind bars, and these short excerpts speak for themselves.

Just people, writing from inside.

 

Our Linktree is live! One easy place to find everything we’re sharing, watching, posting, and building.

✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?

🗣️ Add Your Voice – Submit your responses to our Good, Bad, Change poll 

🤲 Get Involved – Help behind the scenes

💌 Donate Stamps – SOS: Stamp out Silence!

Give – Help us build a world where no one is forgotten

Your Sunday Read: Weekly Recap

Your Sunday Read: Weekly Recap

Pour something warm and settle in.

Catch up with the week’s stories about justice, resistance, policy, protest, and the power of difference. These weekly recaps are emailed to followers on Sundays. If you’d like it in email form (just once a week, no spam ever), you can subscribe here. Otherwise, check into the blog any time.



Civics 101: The Law Passed, So Why Is Nothing Changing?
Passing a law doesn’t mean it takes effect, or helps everyone. We break down what really happens after legislation passes, and why many so-called reforms still leave people behind.

 


In the News: Anti-ICE Protests in L.A.
From Los Angeles: Anti-ICE protests, immigration raids, and powerful voices calling out injustice. Featuring excerpts from Democracy Now and journalist Jean Guerrero.

 




Policy vs. People: I Thought Debtor’s Prison Was a Thing of The Past?

Can you be jailed for missing a payment? In some courts, yes. We unpack how “pay or stay” sentencing turns poverty into punishment, and why it still happens today.

 


Fact Check Friday: They’re Just Doing Their Jobs
Unmarked agents. Rubber bullets. No warrants. We’re fact-checking recent raids and immigration crackdowns and reminding you what your rights still are.

 


Bee Sides: When All the Other Is Gone
Diversity protects forests. And communities. This one’s about photos, the integrity of differences, and what happens when we erase them. Spoiler: It’s not strength.


Also: Fly High, Sly
🙌 🙌 🙌

 


In solidarity,
The Adopt an Inmate Team
🐝 Truth. Connection. Resistance.

Quote of the Week:

I’m of a fearsome mind to throw my arms around every living librarian who crosses my path, on behalf of the souls they never knew they saved.
~ Barbara Kingsolver


Visit our Linktree to find everything we’re sharing, watching, posting, and building.

✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?
🗣️ Add Your Voice – Submit your responses to our Good, Bad, Change poll
🤲 Get Involved – Help behind the scenes
💌 Donate Stamps – SOS: Stamp out Silence!
 Give – Help us build a world where no one is forgotten
Forward This Email – Someone needs to see this

 

When All the Other Is Gone

When All the Other Is Gone

Welcome to Bee Sides
short reflections on justice, hope, and the human spirit

This series is a corner of our blog where I gather stories, books, and unexpected moments that linger long after the first glance.

Most will tie back to incarceration, justice, and the quiet fight for dignity. But sometimes? It’ll simply be whatever refuses to let go. Because that’s what Bee Sides are for.

Let me know what you’re reading, watching, or wondering about. Maybe it’ll make the next issue.


 

🌿 This one’s about what happens to a forest – and a people – when differences are smothered.

When I was in high school in Tulsa, Oklahoma in 1980, there was one Asian guy in our entire school. Surprisingly, in a midwest, bible-belt city that was home to the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre, a place with deep scars from white supremacy and cultural erasure, he was popular, and people were genuinely drawn to what made him unique. 

I’ve been thinking about him a lot lately, and about what happens when the ‘other’ is erased. Not just from schools, but from churches, city councils, neighborhoods, books, plays and TV shows, investment portfolios and corporate boards, and history itself.

Part of our original mission statement (written by Rick from prison) was, “to help those sentenced emerge from prison whole, knowing they are part of a larger family that loves and cares for them.”

So let’s talk about wholeness. What does it even mean?

I know what it doesn’t mean. The way Rick wrote that … “part of” something larger. Can you feel that? Whole isn’t just one thing.

Sameness is not safety. It’s sterility.

We see it in agriculture. Healthy soil teems with diversity … microbes, fungi, worms, nutrients in perfect balance. Remove that variety by planting a single crop over and over, and you’re left with dust and erosion.

On the subject of monocultures, Michael Pollan writes:

This is something nature never does, always and for good reasons practicing diversity instead. This is perhaps the greatest efficiency of a farm treated as a biological system: health.

Pollan also notes that monocultures are supremely vulnerable to pests, requiring tons and tons of pesticides. We’ve thus created a cycle of the opposite of health. For the goal of too much same.

We see it in scripture. Paul’s letter to the Corinthians says: ‘The eye cannot say to the hand, “I don’t need you!” And the head cannot say to the feet, “I don’t need you!” On the contrary, those parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable.’

We see it in investments. Every financial advisor will tell you: Security requires variety.

For reasons that are net yet understood, attempts by food scientists to remove or isolate a single nutrient from a whole food, with the intent to boost it’s benefit, often backfires.

Integrity is not purity, but the state of being undivided. We need it all.

And yet … here we are again. Watching history repeat itself. Books banned. Cultures erased. Languages silenced. Communities driven out. We already saw native tribes forced to abandon their traditions and language, toward the goal of assimilation, in their own lands. During WWII, we saw entire American families of Japanese descent removed from society and locked up based on their ancestry alone. Today, efforts to roll back diversity in public life, to fear and flatten difference, and ultimately erase it, are again front and center.

The great and wise Wendell Berry wrote:

There is an uncanny resemblance between our behavior toward each other and our behavior toward the earth. The Unsettling of America (1977).

The line that connects the bombing of civilian populations to the mountain removed by strip mining … to the tortured prisoner, seems to run pretty straight. We’re living, it seems, in the culmination of a long warfare – warfare against human beings, other creatures and the Earth itself.”
Commencement address at Lindsey Wilson College (14 May 2005)

Prison is designed to convince you that you don’t matter, that the world is better off without you. Some institutions have a policy against people being in possession of any photos of themselves, whether alone or with others. They’ll claim this is for ‘security’ reasons, but we know that the first step of an abuser is to isolate.

For Rick’s first Christmas behind bars, I contacted a bunch of his friends and asked for photos of them with him, and had them made into a photo album – one of the few items besides letters that are sometimes allowed in through the mail. He told me it was the best gift he could have gotten.

“It reminded me that I’m part of something.”

There it is. Wholeness. We all belong to each other. 

Speaking of belonging … I can’t end this Bee Sides without acknowledging the passing of Sly Stone, who wrote the timeless anthem Everyday People, making the musical point that harmony is made up of all our different notes. If you’re a fan, check out Questlove’s documentary, Sly Lives!

Fly high, Sly.  🙌 🙌 🙌

 

Sometimes I’m right and I can be wrong
My own beliefs are in my song
The butcher, the banker, the drummer and then
Makes no difference what group I’m in

I am everyday people, yeah, yeah

There is a blue one who can’t accept
The green one for living with
A fat one tryin’ to be a skinny one
Different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and scooby-dooby-dooby
We got to live together

I am no better and neither are you
We’re all the same, whatever we do
You love me, you hate me
You know me and then
You can’t figure out the bag I’m in

I am everyday people

There is a long hair
That doesn’t like the short hair
For being such a rich one
That will not help the poor one
Different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on, scooby-dooby-dooby
We got to live together

There is a yellow one that won’t
Accept the black one
That won’t accept the red one
That won’t accept the white one
Different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and
Scooby-dooby-dooby

I am everyday people

🗣️ What makes you feel whole?
Have you ever felt erased, or deeply seen? What do you notice vanishing from your community, your classroom, your faith space, your feed?

Scroll down to share your thoughts in the comments, or share a story, a memory, or a moment, big or small, that reminded you we belong to each other.

🐝 Get Involved – Help behind the scenes
✍️ Take the Quiz – How much do you know about U.S. prisons?
Give – Fuel the mission

📚 Fact‑Check Friday: Do Prisons Make Us Safer?

🔍 Fact Check Friday: “They’re just doing their jobs.”

CLAIM: “These officers are just enforcing the law. They’re rounding up violent criminals who don’t belong here.”

🔎 FACT CHECK:

🛑 FALSE. What’s happening on our streets isn’t law enforcement, it’s state-sanctioned terror.

🚨 What We’re Seeing:

Heavily armed, masked agents:

  • No identification
  • No warrants
  • No probable cause
  • No Miranda rights
  • Shooting rubber bullets and chemical agents at peaceful protesters and journalists
In America:
  • You have a RIGHT to protest.
  • You have a RIGHT to know who is detaining you.
  • Agents need a WARRANT or PROBABLE CAUSE.
  • Masked paramilitary forces dragging people into unmarked vehicles is ILLEGAL.

What we’re witnessing in cities like Los Angeles and Nashville isn’t “immigration enforcement” - it’s extrajudicial abduction. It's kidnapping and human trafficking.


🧨 Being undocumented is not a crime.

It’s a civil offense, not grounds for violent raids.

Yet workers - cooks, janitors, dishwashers, farmhands - are being hunted like fugitives, while real threats walk free in positions of power.


💬 Quote of the Week:

I’ve never in my life feared an immigrant or a trans person. I’ve feared the men in my church, the white men in office, and now the armed men hiding behind masks, badges, weapons, and lies.

[...] and i hope they remember the Nuremberg trials, because this fever is going to break, and you will be held accountable for your crimes.
Monte Mader


🗣️ We Need to Say It Plain:

This is not about safety.
It’s not about law and order.
It’s about control and power, and using fear, and cruelty to get it.
That's called fascism.


📣 Your Rights (Even Now):

✅ You do not have to open the door to ICE without a signed judicial warrant.
✅ You have the right to remain silent.
✅ You have the right to record in public.
✅ You have the right to protest.
✅ You have the right to legal representation.

Know them. Use them. Defend them.


❤️ Call to Action

🧵 Share this post.
📬 CALL AND WRITE your lawmakers.
🎤 Speak out. 
💰 Support local immigrant aid organizations.

Because when they come for them, they’re coming for us all.

Want to see more posts like this? Subscribe.

Challenge the Myth
Share this post with someone who needs to see it

✍️ Take the Quiz
Think you know how the justice system works?

🗣️ Share Your Story
Have you or a loved one faced an unfair sentence or wrongful charge?

💌 Donate Stamps
We fight these myths every day, and we do it by mail.

❤️ Support the Work
Your donation fuels education, advocacy, and dignity.

CHAT